1.3 Electric Fields of Finite Objects
We can define the electric field for any number of
distributions now that we know how to apply Coulomb's
Law in combination with integral calculus. One of
the hallmarks of truly "learning" a subject though
is that you first learn "what" neat things you can do,
then you learn when not to do them. In other words,
it's much more important to understand the importance
of symmetry in determining electric fields than it is
to memorize the formulas for any particular charge
distribution. Symmetry reduces the amount of effort
required to get from charge distributions to E fields
to the point where the memorization is actually more
work than deriving the answer when you need it.
A couple of examples are in order:
1.3.1 Electric Field for a Ring of Charge
Prob. 1
The ring of charge below has a charge +q
uniformly spread around a ring of radius R as shown below.
What is the electric field direction and magnitude at the center
of the ring?
Solution 1:
In this case no calculation is necessary.
If we break the ring into infinitesimal pairs, each
with charge dq and arc-length ds, we see that the electric
fields from the pairs cancel as long as the members of
the pairs are chosen so as to be on opposite sides of
the ring as shown in figure 1.9.

Figure 1.9: Electric field at the center of a
uniform ring of charge +q.
That is to say, the electric field is zero since each
infinitesimal dq we pick
around the ring has its field canceled by another
dq diametrically opposite it.
1.3.2 Electric Field for a Dipole Ring Charge
Prob. 2
Suppose the ring above has the top half possessing a
positive charge +q and a negative charge -q on the
bottom half (see the figure below).
Now what is the electric field at point P?
Soln: Now we need to do some work. First note
that there are two symmetries at work here.
Check the figure below.
We see that for any pair of infinitesimal arc-lengths
on the positive half-ring we can choose the elements
so that the horizontal (i.e. x) components cancel while
the vertical (i.e. y) components add. If we choose
pairs of infinitesimal arc-lengths from the negative
half-ring in the same way, we see that their field
components also add vertically and cancel horizontally.
Thus, we can say on the basis of symmetry alone that
the net electric field points downward at point P.
With the direction known it is now just a question of
calculating the magnitude of the net E field. For each
infinitesimal arc-length, we have
as the magnitude of E field produced at the center.
To give each dq a location, we can use the angle
w.r.t. the vertical (note that we could use the angle
w.r.t. the horizontal just as easily). Then, this
angle defines the vertical component of dE at point P.
Therefore, we can find the net field contribution of
the pair of infinitesimal arc-lengths as
|
dEnet = dEy + dEy = 2k |
dqcosq R2
|
|
| (1.3.2.12) |
Now we take advantage of one of our symmetries to only
calculate the vertical components since the horizontal
components all add. We can take advantage of the second
symmetry when we are done calculating the field due to
the top half-ring since the bottom must contribute the
same field at point P. Thus, we do the calculation for
the top half then multiply by two to get the answer
for the entire charge distribution (top half-ring
positive and bottom half-ring negative).
To do the calculation for the top half-ring, we need
to parameterize dq in terms of theta. That's easy
enough in that the linear charge density of the top
half-ring is q/(p*R) since
p*R is the circumference
of a half-ring. The arc-length of dq is R*dq.
So, now we are set to do our integration to find the
net field due to the top half-ring. Note that, since
we are doing pairs of dq's, we only need to integrate
from 0 to p/2 (i.e. a quarter-circle).
Also note that we will use l for the
linear charge density.
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
|
2kq pR2
|
|
é ê
ë
|
sinq |
ù ú
û
|
p/2
0
|
|
| |
|
| (1.3.2.13) |
|
1.3.3 Electric Field for a Rectangular Sheet of Charge
Example 3:
Find the direction and magnitude of the electric field for
a sheet of charge -Q uniformly spread over an infinitely
thin rectangular sheet of length l and width w, as
shown in figure , at a point P
located a distance h above the midpoint of the sheet.

Figure 1.13: An infinitesimally thin sheet of charge -dQ
with length l and width w. The electric
field is evaluated at point P a distance h
above the midpoint of the sheet.
1.3.3 Electric Field for a Rectangular Sheet of Charge
Solution 3:
We could do this problem by breaking the sheet of charge into
tiny rectangles of length dx and width dy, treat these
infinitesimal rectangles as point charges, find the electric
field contribution at point P for each rectangle, then
do a two-dimensional integral to find the net electric field
at point P. This would be quite tedious. We can instead
note that there are symmetries here which allow us to exploit
a solution to a previous problem. First, note that our result
for the electric field at a point located a distance h from
the midpoint of a line of charge q with length l is
We derived this result in the
previous
lecture. We make use of
it now by noting that the result is true for any point
a distance h from the midpoint of the line of charge no
matter what it's orientation. This is called
cylindrical symmetry.
The direction of the
field is radially inward, i.e. toward the line of charge, if
the charge is negative, but the magnitude is unaffected. That
means we can use this result for the current problem since all we
need do is to assume that our sheet of charge is composed of an
infinite number of infinitesimal lines of charge, each with length
l and width dy as shown in the figure below.

Figure 1.14: A sheet of charge -Q of length l and width
w broken into lines of length l and width dy.
Note that we show only two of these lines, both a distance
y from the midpoint, to point out the symmetry that
proves that the net electric field of the two is directed
perpendicular to the plane and toward it from point P.
We define the position of each line as distance y from the
center of the sheet and let each have a charge dQ. Then the
magnitude of the electric field at point P due to each line is
The direction of this field contribution is towards the line.
If we consider pairs of lines, each having charge dQ,
and located y above or below the center of the sheet, then
we can exploit cylindrical symmetry again: each rectangle
contributes a field whose component parallel to the sheet
cancels the parallel component of the other rectangle. We
are left with the perpendicular components of the electric
field due to both rectangles adding. Therefore, for two
rectangles, a distance y above/below the center of the
sheet, the net electric field has magnitude
|
dEnet = |
2·2k dQ
|
cosf = |
4k dQ
|
· |
h
|
= |
4k dQ
|
| Ö
|
l2 + 4h2
|
|
| ______ Öy2 + h2
|
|
|
| (1.3.3.19) |
where f represents the angle of the electric field
vector with respect to a line perpendicular to the plane
of the charge sheet. To integrate over all rectangular
charges dQ, we first need to note that
Then the net electric field when we integrate over all
pairs of rectangles is directed from point P towards
the midpoint of the charged sheet and has magnitude
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
|
4kQ
|
ln |
é ê
ë
|
y + |
| ______ Öy2 + h2
|
|
ù ú
û
|
w/2
0
|
|
| |
|
| (1.3.3.21) |
|
Send comments to larryg@upenn5.hep.upenn.edu.
This page was last modified on 01/17/2003 at 12:30:48 (EST).
Current date/time is Saturday, 07-Nov-2009 19:44:57 EST
06996 hits since